Tuesday, June 27, 2023

On the Treatment of Gender Dysphoria

On the Treatment of Gender Dysphoria

 

Gender dysphoria is certainly a real disease, or no-one would consent to the treatments; but its nature and cause are not well understood.

Medicine often goes through three stages in the treatment of poorly-understood diseases:

1. Placebos. Do no harm, so do nothing. Minor palliation, close observation, and let the disease take its course. This is simple, cheap, painless, and ineffective.

2. Intervention. Aggressively act against symptoms. Surgery, drugs, hormones, etc. Do harm to undo greater harm. This is expensive, dangerous, painful, and partly effective.

3. Cure. Targeted intervention on underlying causes. This is simple, cheap, safe, painless, and fully effective.

For instance, level 1 in the treatment of tuberculosis involved bed-rest; level 2 involved surgical removal of infected lung tissue; and level 3 is an injection of antibiotics.

Achieving level 3 requires deep understanding of the biology involved. It needs Nobel-prize level research. The key insights will likely be found by accident. Until then, suffering is inevitable. It’s nobody’s fault, but it’s everybody’s problem.

We are not at level 3, because we do not know what gender is. Therefore we cannot efficiently fix it when it goes wrong.

Let me risk controversy by speculating that a level-3 gender dysphoria cure will change brain and mind to fit the body, rather than the body to fit brain and mind. I imagine a helmet that irradiates the brain with computer-controlled magnetic fields; after wearing it, the patient becomes a man-in-a-man’s-body, or at least becomes okay with being a woman-in-a-man’s-body. That cures the dysphoria. (Reverse the sexes for FTM.)

Just for fun, let’s imagine that the magneto-helmet makes a BZORT sound when it turns on and off, and a MWOWM sound in-between. Such is my science-fictive speculation.

If a magneto-helmet treatment for gender dysphoria were invented, then would some refuse to wear it? Obviously this involves philosophical questions, such as the illusory nature of identity. Also there are political issues.

Until we conquer our own ignorance of the neurobiology of gender, I recommend that we practice the virtues of patience, stoicism, and compassion.

 

Monday, June 26, 2023

The Honey-Bee Rule

          The Honey-Bee Rule

 

Here’s a modest proposal for the police:

Kill A Civilian, Lose Your Job.

          If a policeman kills a civilian, then he’s kicked off the force, immediately, automatically, and permanently. No delay, no exceptions, no appeals. The policeman gets pension and honors if the review board says he did right, without pension and with prosecution if the review board says he did not; and the review board has civilians on it, and its proceedings are public. The cop gets job placement and PTSD counseling; we owe him that much. But he must never do public  policing again; he owes us that much.

Call this the “Honey-Bee Rule”, for under this rule, the policeman’s weapons are like a honeybee’s stinger; career suicide to use.  Even when killing is justified, killer cops must leave the force.

          The Honey-Bee Rule must be enforced rigorously. We know what happens when we are lax about this. The police swagger, their trigger fingers get itchy, and they tell juries, “I feared for my life when he pulled out his wallet”. Such cowardice becomes systemic.

Under the Honey-Bee Rule, the police will lose their subsidized love of military hardware, and will insist on less lethal options. For instance, talking the suspect down, like they do in civilized countries.

Automatic dismissal for homicide is hard on the police. They will complain that this rule creates impossible professional dilemmas. All true, but nonetheless, this check on police power is necessary. After all, who is to be boss? The police or the people? The boss gets to be a jerk; the servant must say yessir. Tyranny is when the police get to be jerks; liberty is when the people get to be jerks. I choose door #2.

 

 

Friday, June 23, 2023

The Demon of Politeness and the Angel of Rudeness

The Demon of Politeness and the Angel of Rudeness

 

On the first day of class, I tell my students, “Sometimes I will be talking, and a small point will puzzle you. Then a demon and an angel will appear on your shoulders. The Demon of Politeness will say, ‘Don’t ask! You’ll only look foolish. All these other people aren’t asking, so they must know. Besides, it’s bound to clear up later.’ The Demon of Politeness is lying! Meanwhile, the Angel of Rudeness will be saying, ‘ASK! ASK! ASK!’ Listen to the Angel of Rudeness! Rest assured that when you do ask, at least a half-dozen other people in this room will silently thank you!”