Part 11.
Metamathematical Reforms
Here are two Metamathematical Reforms based upon these principles:
To
the Roman Catholic Church: Forget the mad heresy of Papal Infallibility; for
infallibility is jinxed. Instead proclaim a doctrine of Papal Necessity, for
necessity is charmed. Even a backwoods Protestant bear-hunter will rudely agree
that the Pope is necessarily Catholic; and the flock will discover that a
necessary Pope is much more adaptable than an infallible one. An infallible
Pope must accumulate errors; but a necessary Pope can correct errors. Indeed,
error-correction is what a necessary Pope is most needed for. A necessary Pope is corrigible.
And
to the State of Israel: Forget the mad demand for a Right to Exist. There is
no such thing as a right to exist. Existence is jinxed; it’s an accomplishment,
not a given; it cannot be guaranteed. Fortunately there’s a right to Self-Determination,
and even a right to Self-Defense. These are universal, hence charmed.
Self-determination and self-defense aren’t as soothing as self-existence would
be, but self-existence doesn’t work, and they do, sort of, and they’ll just
have to do.
No comments:
Post a Comment