Debby
and Barbie
There’s a saying that the “Difference between law and in-law
is you can justify yourself before law
(long pause) …………but never
before your in-laws.”
Every spring, my husband, Nathaniel, my daughter, Hannah, and
I travel to Boston for a reunion with his family. Nat is the youngest of five. I love them all, but it’s like coming into a
play somewhere during Act Two. They know
their history; I’m reading the program notes.
Everyone got cast in their roles long before I showed up. I’m an extra
in Aida; I’ve got my spear, and I’m just watching the elephants march on by.
The entire sibling cast was assembled on the first night of
our visit, last year. The great dramatic
question: where do we want to go out for
dinner?
MARC, the
overachieving, athletic, oh-my-god-he’s-such-a-perfect-golden son that the
family thinks he spreads rainbows wherever he walks: How about seafood? Very healthy.
DAN, the ex-hippie, now a computer
geek and family man:
It’s gotta have some vegetarian food for me.
SETH, the patient middle-school
teacher who talks to us like we are his 8th grade students: Mark, I’m sick of seafood. Why not a Chinese restaurant?
NATHANIEL, my husband. Call Central Casting for an “absent minded
mathematics professor” and they’ll send him over right away: Chinese food on this coast isn’t nearly as
good as in San Francisco. How about an
Italian restaurant?
DEBBIE, the oldest
sibling. The only daughter. Thin, intense. A closet smoker. She has a PhD in Clinical Psychology and
thinks she knows everything about human motivations: Italian food?! Are you crazy? Do you know how many carbs there are in
pasta? And how rich those sauces are? You know, Nathaniel, you really need to watch
what you are eating. You eat too much,
and I am worried about you. (PAUSE) You
know what, fine. I don’t need to go,
anyway. If you all want to go to an
Italian restaurant, go without me. I’m
not coming with you. I’ll stay here and
eat whatever is in the house.
Ah,
Debbie. Years ago, I coined a name for
her unique affliction: Harpy’s
Tourettes. The enhanced ability to
recognize and obsess upon another person’s insecurities combined with a
complete inability to SHUT UP ABOUT IT.
My turn, channeling my inner Butros
Butros Ghali diplomat: Debbie, you know we don’t want to go without
you, because we hardly ever see you.
Let’s just talk about it some more.
I bet we will figure out something.
A few minutes later, miraculously, we found something on
which everyone could agree: a Thai restaurant.
It turned out to be lovely and upscale place. We got one huge table for all of us. Hannah was next to me, on the end.
Information for anyone who has never been to a Thai restaurant with a nine year
old girl: Thai food is weird. Curry is too spicy and that vegetable dish
looks really strange and the chicken noodle soup has green stuff in it. I slipped into Mom mode.
OK, Hannah, you know the rule: I want you to try some of this, but you never
have to eat anything you don’t like.
This is a different from what you are used to, and I want you to at
least taste it.
But it’s weird. This
one has pencil shavings in it.
Hannah, those are not pencil shavings. It’s called lemon grass. It is an herb that makes the dish a little
sour. It tastes like lemon, see? You don’t eat the lemon grass, just leave it
on the side of your plate.
I don’t like it.
Fine, okay, give that food to me, put it on my plate, I’ll
eat it. Here, try this tofu dish.
What’s this wormy thing?
It’s not a worm, it is a baby corn. It is just like the big ears of corn we eat
sometimes, only this one is so small you can eat the whole thing. Try it.
It tastes good.
Yeah, this is okay. I
like it.
She
likes it! Yaaay! Hey, folks, could you please pass down more
tofu. Hannah thinks it’s good. Now, why don’t we try this eggplant….
By the end of the meal, I felt pretty good. Hannah had gotten enough to eat, and I
praised her for letting herself be open to trying something new. I’d enjoyed the food, myself, and had tried
some dishes I’d never had before.
Good choice.
It took a minute before I realized that someone standing next
to me at the table. It was Debby. She was frowning. She leaned into me intensely.
“I am really worried about what you are doing to your
daughter. Do you realize how much food
you have been eating tonight? Do you
realize how much you have been making her eat?
I’ve been watching you, and I don’t like what I see. You can’t go on in denial about this. I am really very, very worried.”
(let time freeze good mood vanished look around and realize
where I am)
They are all watching
me. Anything I do is gonna be the part
of the family chronology for years.
Oh, crap.
Hannah,
I don’t want to stay here, so I am going for a walk. You can come with me, or stay here at the
dinner table with Daddy. Either one is
okay.
I
want to come with you, Mommy.
I took Hannah’s hand.
We walked out of the restaurant into the cool Boston evening.
Hannah, I’m really mad at Aunt Debby right now. That’s why I wanted to leave the
restaurant. I just feel really
GRRRR! Are you okay?
Yeah, Mommy, I’m fine.
OK, good. Look, there
is a drugstore over there. Let’s go
inside for a while.
The drugstore was a typical, generic Walgreens. We entered and Hannah of course went straight
for the toys aisle. I walked to the
magazine racks. Maybe I just needed
something to read for a while.
Ladies
Home Journal. Redbook. Cosmopolitan.
Seventeen. Elle. Glamour. Allure
Vogue. Self. Shape.
Weight Watchers.
Hannah?
Sweetheart? Let’s go. I am done here.
I avoided Debbie the rest of our visit, and I was really glad
to leave Boston a few days later. I’d
had enough of the in-laws drama for a while.
As
a treat for Hannah, a few days after we returned to San Francisco, I took her to a matinee of the stage version
of High School Musical at the Orpheum Theatre downtown.
It was a fun, light show.
The essential question: Can the
Jock and the Brainiac find happiness together while succeeding in their
academic and sports interests and also singing the leads in the High School
play, even though the mean kids are conspiring to take it all away from
them? The answer is, yes, of course they
can. This is a Disney show, duh?
Come
on, Sweetheart. Let’s get out of
here. Did you like the show, Hannah?
Yeah,
it was great!! Wow, there’s a lot of
people in this theatre. We’re moving
really slow.
Hey,
Hannah, you know what I say?
What?
Baaaa.
Yeah,
baaa.
Baaa.
Baaa.
From
behind me, I hear:
UGH, lose some weight!
HEY!
I
turn around quickly. Oh, wow. It’s Golden Age Barbie! She’s about seventy years old, and she is
wearing her coordinated go-to-theatre outfit.
A basic black dress, matching shoes and handbag. Perfect hair and makeup of course. Her red
earrings and necklace set are the exact
same shade as her lipstick. I’ve never been able to do that!
The
Barbie doll I had when I was a kid was eternally poised, with this glazed
half-smile on her face. Golden Age
Barbie looks downright terrified.
Barbie
sees the look on my face and turns around, trying to walk away from me as fast
as she can. We’re in a crowd of people,
though, and she rather reminds me of a salmon swimming upstream. I grab Hannah’s hand, and follow her.
Barbie
reaches a point where she simply can’t go any further and she has to turn
around to face me. I don’t see the
crowd. There is no one in the room but
her and me and the little girl holding tight to my hand.
EXCUSE ME?!!! I’ve
never seen you in my life and yet you think you have the right to insult
me? How dare you! Who do you think you are?!! I’m here to take my girl to a nice show, and
for no reason you think you can make fun of me?! Your behavior is rude and cruel. They say that age brings wisdom, but that’s
clearly not true in your case! You ought
to be ashamed of yourself. SHAME ON
YOU!!
I keep holding Hannah’s my hand as we walk to our car. I keep the engine off, and I sit her in the
front seat next to me.
Hannah, checking in.
Are you okay?
Yeah, I guess. I’m
kinda nervous. You scared me because
you were shouting, and you never shout.
Yeah. I was really
angry. But you know I wasn’t mad at you,
right?
Yeah. I guess I was
scared because I wasn’t expecting it.
You just started shouting at that lady.
Well, I’m sorry if you feel bad. I just lost my temper. Do you get what was going on?
Yeah that lady was mean to you, and she told you to lose
weight, and you didn’t do anything to her.
That’s right. It’s
wrong to say mean things to people and to hurt their feelings. I am sorry if I scared you, though. I guess I’m still mad at Aunt Debbie, and
when that lady insulted me for no reason, it was just like the last straw, and
I lost it.
That’s okay.
And
we still had a good time at the show, right?
Yeah,
it was great!
You
know, except for you being bothered by it, I’m not really sorry I yelled at
that lady. Maybe she’ll think twice
about insulting strangers in public again.
I don’t know. I guess I’m still
really mad at her.
Yeah, mommy. It’s
okay. I love you and I’m proud of you.
I love you, too, baby girl.
………………………….
That
night, after Hannah was asleep, I took some time alone to think.
I
don’t know if I did the right thing or not.
The world is full of mean and inconsiderate people, and you can’t just
blow your stack at every one of them.
How do I teach Hannah to handle cruelty while keeping her equilibrium
and sense of self worth?
And I think about Golden Age Barbie, too. How did she get to where she is? Why did she think it was appropriate to
insult a harmless stranger, in public?
Why did she care so much about my body size in the first place?
The
world is full of people like Golden Age Barbie.
Snap judgments and casual cruelty are just facts of life. I am a fat person, and that means I am a
premium target for it.
Hannah has got my genes.
There is no way she’s going to grow up to be a thin person. I can do what I can for her. I can feed her right, make sure she
exercises, do what I can to enhance her self esteem. I’m proud to see that she doesn’t have an
eating disorder. But I can’t fight
Mother Nature, either, and I can’t protect her from unkindness in her
life.
What if she’s destined to be a big woman when she grows
up. What do I tell her? What can I teach her? How do I give her the tools to find
confidence and self esteem when there are so many forces lined up to take it
away from her?
And, the big question, what I don’t understand: why is the world so messed up about us fat
people in the first place?