Monday, October 1, 2018

Ford-Kavanaugh Troika


Ford-Kavanaugh Troika


Moe:
Judge Kavanaugh is qualified.
If Dr. Ford is credible, then Judge Kavanaugh is not qualified.
Dr. Ford is not credible.

Larry:
If Dr. Ford is credible, then Judge Kavanaugh is not qualified.
Dr. Ford is credible.
Judge Kavanaugh is not qualified.

Curly:
Dr. Ford is credible.
Judge Kavanaugh is qualified.
Dr. Ford is credible, yet Judge Kavanaugh is qualified.


So by 2/3 majorities, the Stooges rule each of these:

Dr. Ford is credible.
If Dr. Ford is credible, then Judge Kavanaugh is not qualified.
Judge Kavanaugh is qualified.

No comments:

Post a Comment